Finding the Right Hedging Tool in Your Toolbox Relative to Commodity Volatility
You wouldn’t use a hammer for a job that requires a screwdriver, would you? Think about your risk management in the same way. Modern hedging portfolio trends combine different tools and actions to help manage the risk in a portfolio and protect against unpredictable market scenarios. The following graph shows how different market moves create positive or negative outcomes and how a combined portfolio works through the lens of a commodities consumer.
Using different tools makes sense from other aspects as well – cost, availability of credit, impact on working capital, cost/benefit, etc. The table below provides a quick overview.
You can learn more about building a diversified hedging portfolio in and the benefits of diversifying in another article we have posted, so we won’t go into detail on that here.
For this discussion, we are looking at when to use leverage in hedging strategies.
The principle shown in the graph above seems logical. It follows the standard “buy low, sell high” strategy. Now, here are the questions: What is high? What is low? Commodities markets have seen wide extremes in volatility due to the financial crisis, commodity cycles, trade wars and other major economic events.
Currently, volatility in commodities is perceived to be low versus those historical measures, so the next graph (source Bloomberg) attempts to start making sense of how to be alert of different measures that should be part of your consideration set when setting your risk management strategy.
Source: Bloomberg; volatility graph as of September 26, 2019
Definitions
- Three Month Implied Volatility: Derived volatility from current options prices.
- Three Month Realized Volatility: Actual three-month realized volatility in the underlying contract
- Volatility Average: Average Range observed.
- High / Low: Extremes observed during a period of time.
Observing the following should give us a good sense if we should buy options, sell them or use them with measure to design hedging solutions.
- Where is each commodity’s volatility now?
- How is it priced on the ask of options prices?
- What has the actual behavior been in the last three months?
- How do current levels compare versus a period average?
This article is not recommending a specific strategy of either buying or selling options. Instead, the idea is to build on what we know from previous articles and add to that the observations from above. Here are some things to think about:
- Tool selection and mix in a hedging portfolio should not be static. This should be a dynamic exercise.
- As volatility changes, the allocation of percentages of what tools to use should also change.
- As volatility and prices are reduced, analysis should include considering tools buying optionality.
- As volatility and price of options increase, analysis should include considering using the value of options to take advantage in a balanced portfolio (in moderation and with limits).
- Past strategy mix selection success will not guarantee future success when volatility changes.
- Cyclicality should be taken in consideration, since some commodities are subject to seasonal changes in volatility (i.e. agriculture during crop season).
If you have questions about this topic or would like to learn more about leverage in hedging, Cargill Risk Management is here to help!
These materials have been prepared by personnel in the Sales and Trading Departments of Cargill Risk Management, a business unit of Cargill, Incorporated based on publicly available sources, and is not the product of any Research Department. These materials are not research reports and are not intended as such. These materials are for the general information of our customers and are a “solicitation” only as that term is used within CFTC Rules 1.71 and 23.605, as promulgated under the U.S. Commodity Exchange Act. These materials are provided for informational purposes only and are not otherwise intended as an offer to sell, or the solicitation of an offer to purchase, any swap, security or other financial instrument. These materials contain preliminary information that is subject to change and that is not intended to be complete or to constitute all of the information necessary to evaluate the consequences of entering into a swap transaction and/ or investing in any securities or other financial instruments described herein. These materials also include information obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but Cargill Risk Management does not warrant their completeness or accuracy. In no event shall Cargill Risk Management be liable for any use by any party of, for any decision made or action taken by any party in reliance upon, or for any inaccuracies or errors in, or omissions from, the information contained in these materials and such information may not be relied upon by you in evaluating the merits of participating in any transaction. All projections, forecasts and estimates of returns and other “forward-looking” information not purely historical in nature are based on assumptions, which are unlikely to be consistent with, and may differ materially from, actual events or conditions. Such forward-looking information only illustrates hypothetical results under certain assumptions. Actual results will vary, and the variations may be material. Nothing herein should be construed as an investment recommendation or as legal, tax, investment or accounting advice. Cargill Risk Management is a provisionally registered Swap Dealer and operates under “Order of Limited Purpose Designations for Cargill, Incorporated and an Affiliate.”