Transformer Dielectric Fluid Comparison
Compare the typical characteristics and performance of mineral oil, FR3® natural ester fluid, synthetic ester fluid, and silicone transformer oil.
For a more precise estimate tailored to your needs, contact us.
| Mineral Oil | FR3® Dielectric Fluid Natural Ester | Envirotemp® 360 Fluid Synthetic Ester | Silicone Transformer Oil | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base Fluid | Petroleum oil | Plant oil | Hydrocarbons | Polydimethylsiloxanes |
| Voltage Class Applicable | Any, including extra high voltage AC and HVDC | Any, including extra high voltage AC and HVDC | Any, including extra high voltage AC | Mostly limited to 66 kV |
| Fire Point | 160°C | 360°C | >315°C | 343°C |
| Flash Point | 140°C | 330°C | >260°C | 324°C |
| Density at 20°C | 880 kg/cm3 | 920 kg/m3 | 960 kg/m3 | 960 kg/cm3 |
| Pour Point | -35°C | -21°C | <-48°C | -55°C |
|
Kinematic Viscosity 100°C 40°C -20°C |
2 – 3 mm2/sec 8 – 9 mm2/sec 230 mm2/sec |
7.7 – 8.3 mm2/sec 32 – 34 mm2/sec 500 mm2/sec |
6 mm2/sec 34 mm2/sec 1700 mm2/sec |
20 mm2/sec 45 mm2/sec 200 mm2/sec |
| Toxicitya | Potentially toxic | Non-toxic, non-hazardous in soil & water | Not classified as hazardous according to GHS | Potentially toxic |
| Biodegradabilityb | Readily biodegradable; ultimately biodegradable | Readily biodegradable | Not biodegradable (only oxidegradable) | |
| Biobased | No | Yes | No | No |
|
Oxidation Stability Non-free-breathing Free-breathing |
Very good Good |
Very good Not recommended |
Very good Good (moisture control recommended) |
Very good Not recommended |
| Temperature Limits for Normal Lifespan (TUK Paper) |
65 average winding rise 110°C hottest spot |
85 average winding rise 130°C hottest spot |
65 average winding rise 110°C hottest spot |
65 average winding rise 110°C hottest spot |
| Degradation Effects/Consequences | Average; reduces dielectric capacity and produces sludge | Best; long-term impact in viscosity with no formation of sludge | Better; may produce minimal sludge | Average; may produce sludge |
| Transformer reliability | Declines with aging as moisture content in paper and oil increases | Preserves dielectric capacity due to continuous drying of insulation system | May decline as moisture content in paper increases | Typically only used up to 66 kV; no available information |
| Application Location | Indoor & outdoor; requires complex containment & fire mitigation systems | Indoor & outdoor; highly simplified containment & fire mitigation systems | Indoor & outdoor; highly simplified containment & fire mitigation systems | Indoor & outdoor; requires containment system |
a. “Non-toxic” classification for FR3 fluid and Envirotemp 360 fluid is according to IEC6770 requirements and revised EPA definition. “Non-hazardous in water and soil” classification for FR3 fluid Envirotemp 360 fluid is according to GHS.
b. See OECD 301 B (Readily) and Environmental Protection Agency OPPTS 835.3110 (Readily) and 835.3100 (Ultimately).
Related Resources
The products and services described on this website may not be available in all jurisdictions or to all persons.